Field of Dreams

Field of Dreams


This spectacular property is HIGH AND DRY with no wetlands to worry about when applying for permits. The rolling moorlands of Startop offer two unique parcels – a 5.9-acre agricultural preserve plus a 2.1 acre building site with a pre-existing 6,000 SF barn. These parcels offer panoramic land & water views of Lake Montauk, Atlantic Ocean and county parklands offering a rugged, natural beauty from sunrise to sunset. Originally a successful, thoroughbred breeding farm, the ranch was lovingly owned by one family since 1957. The manicured 2.1-acre building lot overlooks a rich pasture of smooth rolling hills and grasslands. Located at its highest elevation, the barn presents as the ideal location for your future home. The adjacent 5.9 acre agricultural preserve presents a unique opportunity for maintaining horses or growing your own food, farm to table. It can also be used as a unique setting for fashion and photo shoots. The property is accessible to thousands of acres of hiking and riding trails all the way to the Montauk Lighthouse. The seller is willing to maintain care of the preserve in exchange for use of a minority share of the preserve. This is an incomparable opportunity to build a four-season estate compound where you can retreat in privacy to a peaceful field of dreams. Included, the seller will sponsor the buyer’s membership to the Montauk Lake Club which can become your interim oasis while designing your dream home at this stunning property.

Co-Exclusive $5,700,000.00


John D’Agostino

Licensed Real Estate Broker

Mobile: 516-885-6919